Women's Basketball Key Bank Player of the Game
| Date | Opponent / Event | Key Bank Player of the Game |
| 11/14/08 | vs. Syracuse | Brittany Wilwohl |
| 11/17/08 | vs. Rhode Island | Heather Stec |
| 11/20/08 | at Boston University | Heather Stec |
| 11/24/08 | at Eastern Michigan | Heather Stec |
| 11/26/08 | at Oakland (Mich.) | Cristina Centeno |
| 11/30/08 | vs. Harvard | Allie Lindemann |
| 12/05/08 | at Canisius | Heather Stec |
| 12/07/08 | at Niagara | Allie Lindemann |
| 12/19/08 | vs. Harvard (Women of Troy Basketball Classic) | Serena Moore |
| 12/20/08 | vs. #8 Duke (Women of Troy Basketball Classic) | Serena Moore |
| 12/30/08 | vs. James Madison | Heather Stec |
| 01/04/09 | at Saint Peter's | Cristina Centeno |
| 01/09/09 | vs. Rider | Heather Stec |
| 01/11/09 | vs. Niagara | Cristina Centeno |
| 01/16/09 | vs. Iona | Heather Stec |
| 01/18/09 | vs. #21 Marist | Allie Lindemann |
| 01/23/09 | at Manhattan | Heather Stec |
| 01/25/09 | at Rider | Heather Stec |
| 01/29/09 | at Fairfield | Serena Moore |
| 02/01/09 | vs. Manhattan | Allie Lindemann |
| 02/06/09 | vs. Loyola | Heather Stec |
| 02/08/09 | vs. Canisius | Sarah Fullmer |
| 02/13/09 | vs. Saint Peter's | Serena Moore |
| 02/15/09 | at Iona | Merrick Volpe |
| 02/20/09 | vs. Fairfield | Allie Lindemann |
| 02/22/09 | at Marist | Cathy Cockrum |
| 02/28/08 | at Loyola | Heather Stec |
| 03/06/09 | MAAC Championships (#3 Fairfield) | Heather Stec |
The Women's Basketball Player of the Game is selected by Mike Demos
Men's Basketball Key Bank Player of the Game & AFSCO Fence "De-FENCE-ive" Player of the Game
| Date | Opponent | Key Bank Player of the Game | AFSCO Fence "De-FENCE-ive" Player of the Game |
| 11/17/08 | vs. Boise State | Kenny Hasbrouck | Alex Franklin |
| 11/22/08 | vs. Cornell | Ryan Rossiter | Ryan Rossiter |
| 11/27/08 | vs. #12 Tennessee (Old Spice Classic) | Alex Franklin | Ryan Rossiter |
| 11/28/08 | vs. Wichita State (Old Spice Classic) | Edwin Ubiles | Edwin Ubiles |
| 11/30/08 | vs. Oklahoma State (Old Spice Classic) | Ryan Rossiter | Ryan Rossiter |
| 12/03/08 | at Loyola | Alex Franklin | Edwin Ubiles |
| 12/06/08 | vs. UAlbany | Edwin Ubiles | Edwin Ubiles |
| 12/09/08 | vs. Marist | Alex Franklin | Ronald Moore |
| 12/17/08 | at #3 Pittsburgh | Edwin Ubiles | Edwin Ubiles |
| 12/23/08 | vs. Buffalo | Edwin Ubiles | Josh Duell |
| 12/28/08 | at Saint Joseph's | Clarence Jackson | Ryan Rossiter |
| 12/30/08 | at Holy Cross | Alex Franklin | Kenny Hasbrouck |
| 01/01/09 | vs. Fairfield | Ronald Moore | Edwin Ubiles |
| 01/04/09 | vs. Saint Peter's | Alex Franklin | Steven Priestley |
| 01/06/09 | at Kansas | Ronald Moore | Kenny Hasbrouck |
| 01/09/09 | vs. Rider | Ronald Moore | Kenny Hasbrouck |
| 01/11/09 | at Manhattan | Edwin Ubiles | Edwin Ubiles |
| 01/15/09 | at Marist | Kyle Downey | Ryan Rossiter |
| 01/17/09 | at Fairfield | Edwin Ubiles | Kenny Hasbrouck |
| 01/24/09 | vs. Niagara | Ryan Rossiter | Ryan Rossiter |
| 01/26/09 | vs. Iona | Kenny Hasbrouck | Ryan Rossiter |
| 01/29/09 | vs. Canisius | Kenny Hasbrouck | Alex Franklin |
| 02/02/09 | at Saint Peter's | Kenny Hasbrouck | Ryan Rossiter |
| 02/07/09 | at Rider | Kenny Hasbrouck | Ryan Rossiter |
| 02/09/09 | vs. Loyola | Alex Franklin | Ryan Rossiter |
| 02/12/09 | vs. Manhattan | Kenny Hasbrouck | Ryan Rossiter |
| 02/16/09 | at Iona | Alex Franklin | Ronald Moore |
| 02/21/09 | vs. Northern Iowa | Clarence Jackson | Ryan Rossiter |
| 02/27/09 | at Niagara | Ronald Moore | Ryan Rossiter |
| 03/01/09 | at Canisius | Kenny Hasbrouck | Kenny Hasbrouck |
| 03/07/09 | MAAC Championships (#9 Canisius) | Edwin Ubiles | Kenny Hasbrouck |
| 03/08/09 | MAAC Championships (#5 Fairfield) | Ronald Moore | Edwin Ubiles |
| 03/09/09 | MAAC Championships (#2 Niagara) | Kenny Hasbrouck | Ryan Rossiter |
| 03/20/09 | NCAA Tournament (#8 Ohio State) | Ronald Moore | Ryan Rossiter |
| 03/22/09 | NCAA Tournament (#1 Louisville) | Edwin Ubiles | Edwin Ubiles |
The Men's Basketball Player of the Game and AFSCO Fence "De-FENCE-ive" Player of the Game awards are selected by Robert Lee and Tom Huerter
